Video Killed The Audio Lecture?

So as part of our summer initiatives, I had the brilliant idea to replicate something that we used to do at another institution where I had worked before: video tutorials for the LMS. I know full well that this may be a futile experience. There’s no possible way to keep up however many videos we do produce, there’s no way to put out the super high quality work I feel is required because we just can’t afford that kind of production time. However, I just couldn’t figure out the quickest way to make sure there’s no technical reason for this initiative to fail other than to crank out several videos, and post them to YouTube so that 20,000 students have some sort of access to information that they can use.

For those of you who haven’t done some sort of screen capture demonstration, here’s what I do. It may not make sense for you, or it may be downright wrong. It works for me – feel free to comment if you have ways that I can improve.

Write the script. 

The script is really the most important thing. It’s what makes you sound professional – you can’t just wing this (unless you’re brilliant). Write the script for what you’re going to say, then record it into your computer. Listen to it. Does it make sense? Good. Is it too long? Do you stumble over phrases? Fix them. Do this months in advance. About two weeks before you actually record, figure out if you can read/recite the script while doing something else. The something else can be typing on the computer, watching a movie… almost anything (I wouldn’t suggest brushing your teeth or having a meal). Can you get through without major issues? Good. It’s good enough to say out loud. Rewrite if you need to. Remember to say why anyone would want to do whatever it is you’re demonstrating. A script, even if it’s simple, will help guide you when you actually do the video. If you think you can skip this step, go ahead. However, I used to feel this way too, and would skip the script – until I was forced to work with one and it made the actual recording process simple.

Know how to do whatever you’re demonstrating.

Really, this is insulting, but it’s amazing how many videos I’ve seen stumble around what they were trying to show. Admittedly, I’m not 100% perfect, I have to often align my mouse up with the things I’m clicking (as my attentions on reading the script). If you happen to say “uhhh, how do I do that again?” stop recording, shut off whatever software you have running and practice the steps. Then practice them again. Make sure you know them inside and out. Do them instinctually.

Decide on what you’re going to record with.

The simplest setup for the best quality is Camtasia. I may be biased because I like the tool a lot, but it’s not open source. I’ve used a ton of tools that do screen capture,  but I know I’ll need the ability to fix audio in post, and edit video. You may like CamStudio, which is pretty damn good – in fact any of the webcasts I did for my early online courses (in 2007/8) used that software. Of course, there’s no post editing options. EZVid also has a similar functions to Camtasia, so I’m interested to try things out.

Nobody wants to see you.

The caveat here is that, nobody wants to see me; you however may look like George Clooney and should be seen. Honestly, people are not looking for a video introduction, so don’t waste time making one. Get to the point. I used to say that there’s a place for a picture-in-picture talking head. Now? I’m not so sure. In certain Distance Education classes it maybe makes some sense, however, the time it takes to do a decent talking head, mix the audio so it matches, and add in the pressure of having to do whatever it is you’re demonstrating in one take, is well, a lot. Cut the extraneous stuff out. Make your video simple and to the point.

Get it done.

I like to record using Camtasia, with a USB Snowball microphone. It’s not a wonderful super duper mic, but it is a good USB microphone at a decent price point. I place the microphone as if I were to speak into it, and then move it to the right of my mouth, so I’m not speaking directly into the mic. It’s a cheap trick to reduce smacking lips, pops and other annoying audio things. You can also make a DIY windscreen if it suits your needs to MacGuyver something. I test audio, and then hit record. Inevitably the first take is usually the one with the most energy, and usually also useless. Listen to it before moving on. Be critical of your performance. Slow down.

One other thing I like to do is take a bit of a break while recording, not like a 2o minute break but 15 seconds or so – don’t move the mouse, don’t do anything in fact. Let your mind reset. Get a bit of a breather and then go on. You can always easily cut out segments of no movement and no audio, as long as you don’t move the mouse no one will be the wiser. Make sure your voice is enthusiastic. As soon as you can’t convince yourself this is important or fun, stop for the day. Go do something else.

Did you go off script? Chances are you did. Make notes where you left the script (you’ll need to transcribe it for captioning if you care about accessibility). YouTube’s captioning ability is pretty amazing.

If you have more energy, go again. You’ll probably find your rhythm. Keep mining that feeling because it is fleeting and you will find it beneficial to make up the time you lost earlier (either in setup, or some other place).

Cut yourself.

No, not with a sharp instrument, but be brutal with your performance. Find three seconds of silence and no movement on screen? Cut it. Find an awkward phrase that can be done without? Cut it. Students, your audience, don’t want to muddle through it. Is the instruction clear? No? Cut it (and in this case, do a voice over). Tighten up the overall rhythm of the video. Do your best to make it flow. Editing yourself will be painful, listening to yourself, is well up there with many uncomfortable things. I think it helps to imagine it’s someone else, but maybe that is delusional.

Small things are important.

Taking the time to get all the small things right is important. They may not mean much individually, but every removal of potential distractions from the content will help your learners. That means every “um” you remove, every breath that you can hear, every awkward pause, whenever you reduce those, you’re making a better product. I personally, like to have a 15 to 30 second introduction – which is simply a couple of pages that I build in Photoshop (you could use Gimp or Paint Shop Pro). Those pages have some sort of identifier, and the topic being covered. I also add a 30 second to a minute  bumper at the end with my institution’s logo on it. If I have time I’ll craft something quick using FruityLoops and Audacity to give the beginning some pep in the audio department. A little four note introduction can help make things seem uplifting, bouncy and set the tone for the rest of the video.

Once the video editing is done really you’re left with tying all the loose ends. Captioning is a big thing, and basically I listen and re-listen and type out the words I actually say. Make sure you export as large a file as possible – in MP4 format with the H.264 codec as a best practice.  Why MP4 and that particular codec? Well, MP4 has become a universal file format and has better compression than MPG/MPEG and has none of the compatibility issues of QuickTime or AVI. That particular codec is also widely used and will be very forgiving. If you’re uploading to YouTube or Vimeo, both sites will take files in those formats encoded in with H.264

That’s it. After the hours it takes to capture and edit, your two minute video will be seen by, well, however many people see it. If you get a year out of it until the next upgrade, you’ll be in good shape.

A Non-Reflective Post For Once…

Interesting couple of days, had a Distance Ed class pop up from nowhere and all of a sudden I’m back in instructor mode. So I took the powerpoints that I present in the face to face version of this course, and do a couple takes of the voice over, in an incredibly noisy office and voila, a weekend later I have five little videos uploaded to the internet that talk about the internet.

The process was quite convoluted. I’m sure I could’ve tried to figure a more streamlined approach. This post is going to be purely nostalgic after I’ve done this a couple times, so if you are interested in how NOT to do this, this post is for you.

On Friday, I updated the powerpoint, having to use Power Point 2007, instead of the old 2003 that was available in my office. So having to figure out where all the things that I used to do automatically was a bit of a learning curve, but nothing too bad. Then do some sort of narration. First I tried using a Firefox plugin called CaptureFox but that didn’t do the job I needed. I wanted something else that was a little more slick. So searching for free/shareware I came across Cam Studio 2.5. Now I realize, I could’ve just walked over to the Centre for Teaching, Learning and Research and used Camtasia, but there’s not a great narration facility there. The Camtasia computer is in fact in a hallway, that’s secluded enough, but I know people over there and it probably would’ve been distracting for me to perform (teaching is a performance isn’t it?). Anyways, Cam Studio did the job. I set it to convert to SWF, and discovered that, to my knowledge which is about 2 hours of use, there’s no way to convert the screen size. And that converting to SWF would take me about 12 hours. I didn’t want to come back to work just to upload my video, so I bailed and came home to use some Adobe product. Surely CS3 will be able to handle this sort of easy task?

Maybe I’m a moron, but it turns out that Premiere Pro CS3 doesn’t convert AVIs to Flash (I did discover that After Effects can, but won’t resize the dimensions of the screen without fuss). Or do anything easily. So again, back to the world of shareware, I found Xilisoft FLV Converter. Took the AVI I had (1.5 gig), resized, converted to FLV and chopped it to the length I needed (10 min segments).

Total time? Started sometime after 2 PM Friday, posted sometime on Sunday (in between Thanksgiving turkey and apple strudel).

Oh yeah, there’s one student enrolled in the distance ed class. Hope they appreciate the effort. (You can too here under “members own videos”).

So the moral of this story is – sometimes technology isn’t the friend of the techie.