Quality or Quantified?

I think that’s what the Quantified Self is, this notion of examining yourself and enabling data about yourself to this super-high degree. For a lot of behavior change, it comes down to either a motivational problem or an information problem. If you are really motivated to change something about yourself, but you just don’t know what to do, then mere information is very valuable. Just doing the Quantified Self ends up causing a behavior change.

The problem is that there are certain issues that even if you know what the right thing is, you don’t do it. Diet is a great example. Almost everyone knows what it means to eat right, and yet the knowing is not enabling the doing. That’s the motivation problem. – Fred Trotter (from an interview over at O’Reilly Radar)

The Quantified Self is the same sort of self-management stuff that the Nike+ or Streaks app, or the aggregation of data through @ mentions on twitter (Your FlowingData) provide. Unfortunately, none of these programming solutions really address what these values mean in some sort of tangible way. Sure, you can correlate your data with averages (that you also have to track down and massage), but it doesn’t tell you necessarily what it means. If I walk 2300 steps today, is that good? What does that mean for a man 20 pounds overweight and 5’10”? Having software deduct money from you isn’t really a good solution to enforce behavioural change, there’s too many simple ways to prevent a computer from doing this – simplest of which would be disassociating the software from the currency. Or putting software in between the two to halt any sort of transaction. It’s easy to think of fairly simple ways to avoid paying the price of change, but wouldn’t it be better if perhaps these programs addressed some of reasons for change, and reinforcing those needs rather than punishing. It seems like these behaviour modification apps are stuck in the pavlovian method of reinforcement. Maybe they can get through this phase relatively quickly and start building software that helps people get motivated to change (if they need to).

2 thoughts on “Quality or Quantified?

  1. Exactly, designing software with a different purpose entirely. I’m not sure one can explicitly design software to motivate beyond what motivation lies inside to begin with, so I don’t know what software that would seek to do this would look like.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.